I'm a Pisces and I've been dating an Aquarius man for just over a year. Everything you read says that Pisces and Aquas should not get along, but we do...wonderfully. I'm pretty sure one day I'll marry this one!
I'm not sure if he's a typical Aqua or not...he's so open and he talks about everything, even the tough topics and he's very good at getting me to open up too. He's honest (to the core) and loyal and faithful, an amazing father, and a wonderful lover...he's truly become one of my best friends too....OK, sorry, now I'm just gushing.
If he has ANY faults, it's that when things get stressfull or life starts moving really fast, he kind of becomes agitated, I've learned that at those moments I really have to just stand back and let him deal with the stress in his own way...he'll talk about it later, but at that moment he just needs to be left alone. He also has a tendency to sometimes blindly not see what his own children are doing (we both have kids) but I'm pretty sure this is more of a single father who has his kids part-time trait, rather than a Aqua trait. Anyway, the things that bother me are completely "work-out-able" and are pretty darn minor in the grand scheme of things.
When I first met him I scoured the internet looking for success stories between Aqua and Pisces and to be honest I was completely disheartened that I found very, very few. In the end it didn't matter because no matter what the stars said, we ARE very compatible!