I'm a Virgo, too but I don't really know that many Pisceans. I can say that there are many types of relationships and just because you get along doesn't necessarily mean you will get along in a long term, day to day way.
For example I know this (married!) Aries woman. I'm really attracted to her but not just in a sexual way or romantic way, I just like her. I feel very comfortable around her. I ran our charts together and although we have a strong emotional and intuitive understading of each other. Also we are indeed drawn to one another there are many other areas where we are not compatible. For example our report says it is likely to be a love hate type relationship.
So you have to remember there are always aspects between people that nurture good feelings while other aspects can stop any potential relationship because those negative aspects will conflict (and not all negative aspects can ruin a relationship) with the good ones.
I wish you (and everyone else in this situation!) the best